경영승계가 조직성과에 미치는 영향
The Impact of the Managerial Succession on Organizational Performance
김계정(선문대학교)
22권 3호, 1133~1164쪽
초록
본 연구에서는 “ 한국기업조직에서 최고경영자 승계와 관련된 변수들은 조직성과와 어떠한 관계가 있는가?” 라는 연구과제에 관한 답을 얻고자, 경영승계에 관한 기존 연구를 고찰하였다. 경영승계에 관한 연구모형과 연구가설을 설정하고 한국의 전체 상장기업 중에서 17개의 산업 중분류 별로 할당한 자료에서 무작위로 138개 기업을 표출하여 가설을 실증적으로 검증하였다. 연구결과 한국기업조직에서는 경영승계가 몇 번 발생했느냐(승계빈도), 승계자가 내부출신이냐 외부출신이냐(승계자의 출신), 또는 명목상의 최고경영자의 경영승계에 따라 경영진이 얼마나 바뀌었느냐(경영진 변동률) 하는 승계요인은 경영승계에 따른 조직성과를 제대로 설명하지 못하는 것으로 나타났다. 오히려 승계 전의 조직성과나 조직규모 같은 조직적 요인이 경영승계 후의 조직성과를 훨씬 더 잘 설명하는 것으로 나타났다. 경영승계 후의 조직성과와 조직성과 변화율(=승계 후 성과/승계 전 성과)면에서 중대규모 기업이 소규모 기업에 비하여 우수한 것으로 나타났다. 이 결과는 조직이 커지면 내부제도가 정비되어 조직이 잘 경영되므로 경영승계가 발생하여도 조직성과 달성에 별 지장을 받지 않는다는 Grusky의 관료제론이나 Pfeffer & Salancik의 복잡성이론의 결론과 도 일치하는 것이다. 본 연구에서는 경영승계에 관한 기존의 연구를 정리하여 경영승계에 보다 효율적으로 대처하는데 필요한 지혜를 찾고자 노력하였고, 한국의 상장기업을 대상으로 경영승계와 관련된 체계적인 실증적 연구를 시도하여 구미의 경영승계연구의 보편적 결론과는 상당히 다른 결과들도 일부 밝혀냈다. 마지막으로 본 연구의 한계와 경영자 승계에 관한 향후 연구방향을 제시하였다.
Abstract
As corporations grow and develop, managerial succession is inevitable to follow. This process is often achieved successfully, allowing the next generation to engender further corporate development. However, managerial succession is not always certain to be successful, and often causes severe social problems. Though corporate managerial successions do not occur often within an individual corporation, on a national scale they are quite frequent. Moreover, when considering the ability of a managerial succession to either stimulate or detrimentally impact corporate growth, managerial succession is a critical issue both nationally and individually. For most big business groups in South Korea, the first generation established and developed business groups throughout the initial stages of industrial development. Recently, this first generation has been succeeded by the second generation and the third generation. Given that managerial succession now occurs in corporations on an individual basis, the issue of managerial succession now poses major implications in the field of business management. Thus, most studies sought to address this issue, focusing on corporate performance. Based on the many resulting theoretical discussions on managerial succession, this study proposes a research model to answer the following research question: What is the correlation between CEO succession and organizational performance in the context of South Korea? In this study, independent variables were divided into organizational factors and succession factors. Specifically, organizational factors included prior organizational performance and organizational size. Succession factors were the origin of each successor, frequency of succession, and changes in top management teams. The dependent variable in this study was organizational performance following succession. To examine relationships between variables, the following hypotheses were derived. H 1: The rate of change in organizational performance (= performance following succession/ prior organizational performance) will be higher. H2: There will be no statistically significant affect on organizational performance by frequency of succession. H3-1: There will generally be no statistically significant difference between the changes in top management team and organizational performance. H3-2: There will be statistically significant relationships between changes in the top management team and organizational performance where outside succession occurs H4: The rate of change of organizational performance will be higher in larger organizations compared to smaller organizations. H5: The explanation power of organizational factors(organizational performance before succession, organizational size) for organizational performance following succession will be stronger than that of succession factors origin of successor, frequency of succession, the rate of changes in top management team). The principal findings of this study are as follows: There were no significant differences in organizational performance dependent on frequency of succession. There were no significant differences in organizational performance whether succession was inside or outside. This can be explained by the unique contextual character of South Korean corporations where there is no clear separation between management and ownership. Thus, in situations where someone wielding actual power operates both ownership and management, organizational performance may not hinge uponthe origins of nominal successor: insider or outsider. Regarding organizational size, larger organizations exhibited a higher rate of organizational performance changes compared to smaller organizations. In other words, large organizations handle new situations following succession more effectively than small organizations. This result supports Grusky’s administrative succession theory and Pfeffer and Salancik ’s complexity theory that as an organization grows, efficiency improves due to the organization’s more orderly arrangement of internal systems. In sum, the following succession factors were considered: the number of managerial successions (frequency of succession), whether the successor was an insider or outsider (origin of successor), and the frequency of changes in the top management team indicating nominal CEO’s managerial succession (rate of change in the top management team). Based upon the proposed model, succession factors cannot explain the operational performances sufficiently. Rather, the results of the study show that organizational factors including organizational performance prior to succession and organizational size may better explain organizational performance following succession. This study is intended to offer important implications for organizations and scholars to manage succession more effectively. Using samples of listed Korean firms, systematic empirical studies on managerial succession yielded dissimilar results from general results of executive succession studies conducted in the West. Furthermore, limitations of thisstudy and directions for future research also are suggested.
- 발행기관:
- 한국산업경제학회
- 분류:
- 경제학