정보와 주가변동성 : 한국증권시장에 대한 실증연구
Information and Volatility:Evidence found in the Korean Stock Market
박진우(한국외국어대학교); 김민혁(예금보험공사)
32권 2호, 141~164쪽
초록
>본 연구는 정보효과론적 관점에서 한국증권시장을 대상으로 주가변동성의 행태와 원천을 분석하였다. 특히, 본 연구의 분석대상 기간 중에 토요일 거래제도 폐지, 점심시간 휴장제도 폐지로 인해 일중 거래시간이 증가했다는 한국증권시장의 독특한 거래제도 변화에 착안하여 거래시간과 주가변동성간의 관계 및 주가변동성의 원천을 분석하였다. 또한, 한국 주식으로서 DR발행을 통해 해외증권시장에 교차상장된 종목을 대상으로 변동성을 분석함으로써 한국증권시장의 비거래시간인 야간동안에 해외증권시장에서 DR 거래를 통한 거래시간 증가가 주가변동성에 어떤 영향을 미치는지 분석하였다.연구결과를 요약하면 다음과 같다. 첫째, 비거래시간 보다는 거래시간동안에 주가변동성이 크게 나타나 한국 증권시장에서도 주가변동성의 거래시간효과가 존재함을 확인할 수 있었다. 둘째, 주가변동성의 원천으로는 French & Roll(1986)의 연구에서처럼 공적정보가설은 기각되고 사적정보가설이 지지됨을 확인했다. 또한, 가격설정오류가 변동성 원천의 일부가 되고 있음을 알 수 있다. 셋째, 주가변동성이 일중 거래시간의 증가와 밀접한 관계를 갖고 있음을 확인하였다. 그러나 점심시간이 거래시간에 포함됨으로써 나타나는 주간변동성의 증가폭은 크지 않은 것으로 나타났다. 넷째, 해외증권시장에 교차상장된 한국 DR의 경우 야간 거래시간의 증가에도 불구하고 야간수익률 변동성이 증가하지 않은 것으로 나타나 단순한 거래시간 증가가 주가변동성에 영향을 주는 것이 아니라 주가변동성은 충분한 거래량이 수반될 때 이를 통해 반영되는 것임을 알 수 있었다.
Abstract
The effect of information on stock return volatility has long been a debatable issue particularly among academic circles ever since the publication of the pioneering work by French and Roll (1986). Their research on stock return behaviors in the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) reveals that stock return volatility during the trading time period is significantly higher than that during the non-trading time period. They suggest that this greater volatility demonstrated during the trading time period is principally due to private information. In succeeding the research by using the data from the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE), Barclay et al.(1990) has also indicated that private information is a main determinant factor of stock return volatility. While an extensive analysis of the effect of information flow on stock return volatility in the global markets is available, only a few research results exist for the Korea Stock Exchange (KSE). Moreover, the extant studies focused merely on the stock return volatility in light of market microstructure of the KSE, and concluded that the unique microstructure features of the KSE were not likely to be the cause of stock return volatility. Therefore, in this study we took a closer look at the KSE with the purpose of analyzing the behavior of stock return volatility computed from the opening and closing prices of KSE stocks and of examining the relevancy of the information to the difference in volatility between the trading and nontrading periods. Specifically, this paper analyzes the ratios of variances of trading period (open-to-close) relative to nontrading period (close-to-open) returns. In addition, this paper examines the impact of global trading of cross-listed Korean stocks on the return volatility during nontrading periods. The sample used in this study includes 100 stocks listed on the KSE and covers the period from January 5, 1998 to August 22, 2000. A few microstructure changes in the KSE have occurred during the sample period. To name a couple are the termination of the Saturday trading session in December 1998 and the abolition of the lunchtime break in May 2000. Taking into account these institutional changes that took place in the KSE, this paper investigates the correlation between the trading hours and stock return volatility and the cause of the higher volatility during trading periods. Main findings of this paper are as follow: First, the variance of stock returns is much higher when the market is open. That is, the trading time effect on stock return volatility exists in the KSE. Second, this higher volatility during trading periods in the KSE is mainly influenced by private information. Thus, the evidence found in the Korean stock market supports the explanation proposed by French and Roll(1986), Barclay et al.(1990), both indicating that private information is the main determinant of the higher volatility during a trading period. Third, this study finds the following correlation: the longer intra-day trading hours, the higher stock return volatility. Yet, the study also reveals that the impact of trading during lunchtime on stock return volatility is not significant. Fourth, the global trading of cross-listed Korean stocks does not affect stock return volatility during a nontrading period of the KSE. This result may be attributed to the insufficient trading volume of the cross-listed stocks in the global market.
- 발행기관:
- 한국증권학회
- 분류:
- 경영학