세무조사 적발위험과 조세회피의 관련성
The Relation between the Probability of Tax-Audit Detection and the Tax Avoidance
박상섭(수원과학대학교)
37권 3호, 41~80쪽
초록
본 연구에서는 세무조사에 따른 적발위험과 조세회피의 관련성을 살펴보았다. 세무조사 받은 기업의 적발위험(조세회피와 세무조사추징세액(적발금액의 위험) 및 세무조사와 관련된 시간에 따른 위험(적발시간의 위험))과 조세회피의 양상을 살펴보았다. 이는 첫째, 조세회피와 세무조사추징세액(적발금액의 위험)의 관련성과 둘째, 세무조사에 대응하는 조세회피의 시기에 따른 양상(적발시간의 위험)을 살펴본 것이다. 연도별로 세무조사전후년의 조세회피추정치와 세무조사추징세액의 관련성을 분석하였다. 세무조사전 4년의 조세회피추정치와 세무조사추징세액은 관련성을 나타내지 아니하였다. 세무조사전 2~3년은 조세회피추정치와 세무조사추징세액이 양(+)의 관련성을 나타내고 있다. 세무조사전 1년의 분석에서는 조세회피추정치와 세무조사추징세액은 음(-)의 관련성을 나타내고 있었다. 세무조사후 1~2년은 조세회피추정치와 세무조사추징세액이 관련성을 나타내지 않았다. 이는 첫째, 세무조사 직전년도에는 세무조사의 적발금액에 대한 위험(적발금액의 위험)이 큰 기업일수록 조세회피의 정도를 줄이는 것으로 해석할 수 있다. 둘째, 세무조사라는 시점을 기준으로 가까이 왔을 때는 적발위험(적발시간의 위험)을 인식하여 조세회피를 줄인다고 볼 수 있다. 세무조사에 대응하는 조세회피의 양상을 분석하기 위하여 세무조사 전1~3년에 이르는 총 3개년의 조세회피가 있는 기업 84개 만을 추가적으로 분석하였다. 그 결과에 의하면 조세회피는 세무조사 직전 3년전이 가장 높았으며, 세무조사 2년전부터 낮아졌다. 세무조사 직전년도에는 조세추징가능성이 높은 기업이 오히려 조세회피를 더 낮게 하는 것으로 나타났다. 세무조사에 대응하는 기업의 조세회피의사결정은 세무조사의 전의 기간에 따라 차이가 나타남을 살펴보았다
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to test the relation between the Probability of Tax- Audit Detection and the Tax Avoidance. The two hypothesis coming below are tested by the data from firms listed in samples. The first hypothesis is that the tax avoidance will have a statistically significant relation to the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits. The second hypothesis is that the tax avoidance will be changed by the timing of tax audit. The dependent variable is the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits. The independent variable is a measure of the sheltering activity. The control variances are dept ratio(Total Liability / total asset), corporate size(Natural logarithm of market value of equity), property ratio(Fixed assets / total asset), ratio of operating cash flow(Operating cash flow / total asset), ownership ratio(Largest shareholders' share), discretionary accruals and retained earnings ratio(Retained earnings/ total asset)As a result of this analysis, the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits has a positive and statistically significant relation to the tax avoidance in the past 3rd and 2nd years before the tax audits. But, in the previous 1st year before the tax audits, the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audit has a non-positive and statistically significant relation to the tax avoidance. The corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits does not have a statistically significant relation to the tax avoidance in the following 1st and 2nd years after the tax audits. The major findings of this study are as follows. First, there is a positive and significant relation between the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits and the tax avoidance. Second, the tax avoidance is related by timing of the tax audit. Decision-makers of those firms tend to decrease the amount of Tax avoidance when they anticipate that tax audit comes close. Decision-makers of those firms tend to increase the amount of tax avoidance when they anticipate that the tax audit is not coming close. tive income before tax were additionally investigated. That is because the financial records of the companies with non-positive income before tax may show low reliability. In this case of research, the same method of above study was adapted. The result of this analysis of the companies with positive income before tax is similar to the result of analysis of all the samples including those with non-positive one. The corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits has a positive and statistically significant relation to the tax avoidance in the past 3nd year before the tax audits. And, in the previous 1st year before the tax audits, the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audit has a non-positive and statistically significant relation to the tax avoidance. But, in the previous 2nd year, there is not statistically significant relation between the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits and the tax avoidance. It is assumed that the companies with positive income before tax are more able to anticipate the possibility of tax audit than the companies with non-positive income before tax. For the deeper investigation of the relation between the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits and the tax avoidance during 3 years, the relation between the measure of tax avoidance over the 3 years just before the tax audit and the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits is need to be studied at once. As a result of the analysis, it is shown that the relation of the corporation tax amount by the result of tax audits and the measure of tax avoidance, in the past 1st year just before the tax audit, is non-positive and statistically significant and, in the 2nd and 3rd year before the audit, is positive and statistically significant Finally, The amounts of the tax avoidance will be decreased by the high detecting risk due to the close timing of tax audit. The tax avoidance will be increased by the low detect risk due to the not coming close tax audit. Therefore, irregular tax audit is to be effective than regular one.
- 발행기관:
- 한국회계학회
- 분류:
- 회계학